Page 1 of 1

Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 06:10
by sheetsofsound
Anyone got any suggestions for this?
Image
Both of them are rusted as h*ll. I've been soaking them for a couple of days in penetrating oil and tried removing them with a bar about 18" long. I'm worried about rounding the nut. Any tricks with this?

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 06:56
by REPLIC8
Lots of heat on the strut tube.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 07:02
by UKPhilTR7
Oh my gosh that looks well in there. I have not seen one that bad before. Good luck with that.

I alos think that heat is the way to go.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 09:31
by sonscar
If you are renewing the inserts you will get new nuts.There may be I staked dimple to drill out that secures the existing nut and you get new nuts with the inserts(usually).Secure the tube and use large hammer and chisel to remove.Good fettling,Steve...

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 15:36
by FI Spyder
Oh boy! You are going to need everything going for you. heat the tube with torch to expand it, blast of cold Freeze It (or similar) to shrink the nut.

http://www.arctic-products.co.uk/products/professional-chemicals/crack-it-shock-freeze-release-spray/

Get some impact on it hammer and chisel or hammer on the wrench, drill the dimple (if you can find it under that rust). These have been mentioned, use them all.

A good dose of patience and perseverance, me Mom would call it stubbornness.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 16:37
by sheetsofsound
Ok. All will get tried tonight, time permitting.

The car it came off had major rust in the turrets. It was my first TR7 and I had no idea how unsafe it was to drive. The PO had bondo-ed the shock tower and had the whole car completely resprayed. It looked fantastic. The gaiter was torn at the top, making a perfect catch basin, filling with water and pooling around the nut.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 20:42
by seven
Be careful if you are going to heat it as the oil does expand. I took my strut to the engineers to ask them to heat up mine and they refused point blank. Said it would explode :shock:
I have heated them up in the past and not had any problems, though I didn't heat it till red hot :mrgreen:

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 13 Jul 2015 22:16
by saabfast
Maybe I was lucky. I put the strut in a large engineering vice and used a pair of 12" Stillsons (pipe wrench) with about 2' of tube over the end. They seemed to come undone more easily that I thought they would.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 14 Jul 2015 00:01
by sheetsofsound
So far no luck, although I haven't tried freezing it yet. I heated it with no adverse effects, but I am nervous to try it again after reading the above post. I have put it in a vise and got some torque on it, but to no avail. There are no dimples to drill out; too much rust. The pipe wrench idea I will try next. Right now its soaking in penetrating oil..again. Some more.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 14 Jul 2015 02:43
by Hasbeen
That dimple is not all that large. It is actually small enough to be hard to find under the paint in a rust free strut. All struts have [or had them] ex factory. Perhaps if you gave them a clean up with a light wire brush, it would become obvious.

We recently shouted the 8 a new set of adjustable gas inserts. It was recently restored when we bought it 12 years ago. We found a drill hole, filled with some epoxy filler, about 3/16" in each strut, where the dimple had been drilled out during fitting the previous strut inserts by the restorers.

They came out very easily.

Hasbeen

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 14 Jul 2015 15:06
by FI Spyder
sheetsofsound wrote:So far no luck, although I haven't tried freezing it yet. I heated it with no adverse effects, but I am nervous to try it again after reading the above post.


My top nut came out with pipe wrench with out drilling out dimple (didn't know about it then) but they were like brand new (not your situation). Do you have any shock action left? Mine had zero, no gas, no oil, I could have tossed them in a bonfire and nothing would have happened. The idea is to heat the tube (making it expand) then freezing the nut with spray (making it contract). I would wire brush as much of the rust off the join as possible. Applying a hammer to it is to crack the rust weld. Persistance is key. I when you get it off be sure to apply some Loctite on the new nut when you put it on. It can back out in use.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 15 Jul 2015 23:36
by Roger27TBB
Hello,

i would saw or mill off the top nut careful in one line without damage the thread of the strut with a saw or small drilling machine and then bend off the top nut a bit to unscrew it.

Hope you are successful. :D
Greetings from Roger27TBB

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 17 Jul 2015 16:48
by sheetsofsound
Well.

I have tried all that has been suggested except drilling out the dimple, as I can't be sure where it is. There have been at least a dozen heat/freeze cycles, (albeit cautiously, as there is some shock action still left), impact, 5 different penetrating oils left on for hours and/or days, different tools applied, I even took it to a local garage. I'd try lighting a candle and communing with aliens if I thought it would help.

Then violence. Not being conversant with the finer points of torture, I may have been a bit heavy-handed with my subject at first. The subject would not give up the goods. Indeed, the physical integrity of the subject began to fail, and still no progress. I am beginning to lose hope.

Image

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 22 Jul 2015 22:05
by sheetsofsound
Well, success of a sort. FI Spyder was right. Perseverance was key. After the nut failed, I mangled it as tight as I could get it in my vise and then used a 5ft piece of pipe over a pipe wrench to give me more torque. Plus heat and freezing.

The carnage:
Image

And the end result:
Image

Victory of sorts, as I'm none too happy with the state of the threads. The other tube was not quite as bad, and I was able to locate the dimple before starting work.
Image

Any opinions or suggestions? Are these still useable? I am new to this part of the car.

Re: Strut insert removal advice

Posted: 23 Jul 2015 00:11
by FI Spyder
I wouldn't. I would get a set from a car that is being parted/wrecked. Even though the car may be rotted out the struts will be good (your situation not withstanding).